Two Approaches to Calculating Bonuses

Posted on by Leave a Comment

There are a lot of traditions surrounding the distribution of bonuses ranging from timing to eligibility, from merit to patronage, from celebration to stomach ulcers. The less pleasant traditions are usually a result of poorly defined structure or “bias bonuses” that reward people based on favoritism and politics rather than contribution.

Photo by Frédéric Bisson, Flickr

To ensure that bonus time creates a positive tradition in your organization, here are two vastly different approaches that strive to address common bonus time inequities.

The Standard Approach

The annual bonus is a common approach used by businesses concerned with preserving cashflow. Typically, bonuses are closely connected to each business’ vision of success.

To ensure that bonuses are distributed fairly, they’re often tied key performance indicators (KPI’s), which then vary by department and job role. Managers may also give out discretionary bonuses, which should be linked to specified goals and objectives (MBO).  

Calculating how much an employee will receive is a function of the intersection of company performance and individual performance during the year. In this way, top performers (who have contributed more to overall company performance) are rewarded accordingly. Of course, annual bonus decisions are also are grounded in one other essential question: can we afford this?

Assuming the company is financially healthy, a bonus scheme is usually calculated based on a percentage of NET profit tied to a minimum benchmark. When the benchmark is exceeded, a contribution to the bonus pool is triggered. The bonus pool is then shared among employees, based on policy (e.g seniority), job roles and performance.

According to, the following are typical bonus levels (as a percentage of salary) for industries that commonly issue bonuses. Some exceptions to this example include the high-tech and investment banking industries, which may offer more generous bonus structures, and the healthcare and nonprofit sectors where bonuses are rare.

Base salary

Target bonus (%)

 Less than $75,000












 $500,000 or more


*Bonuses for this range are not typical, and if rewarded, are usually discretionary.

Something Completely Different

So many aspects of today’s workplace are evolving in interesting and challenging ways that we shouldn’t be surprised at the emergence of unique bonus structures. The way Shopify handles bonuses, for example, is highly exceptional. They crowdsource their bonuses based on peer feedback and hand them out monthly. At Shopify, a person’s bonus is “determined by the gratitude of her peers for a job well done.”[1]

Their logic for this approach is as follows: although good work ultimately benefits external customers, it also makes the lives of co-workers easier. While dissatisfied customers can complain or shop elsewhere, the people we work alongside see (and have to live with!) the impact of our behavior and our efforts every day.   

Which is why, following the internal implementation of iDoneThis as a team productivity tool, Shopify introduced what they call the Unicorn system. Colleagues log instances when the people they work with have done something awesome. These comments drive the bonuses distributed each month. As a result, praise and bonuses are handed out when deserved, based on real contributions as determined by peers. According to Shopify CEO, Tobi Lutke, “Unicorn discovered top performers among employees who might otherwise have been overshadowed by more charismatic colleagues.”

With this non-traditional approach, Shopify took the politics out of bonuses. Also, by giving bonuses every month, they tied feedback far more closely to results, taking advantage of the fact that timely reinforcement is so much more powerful than delayed recognition when it comes to performance.

Whether your company subscribes to the more traditional approach to calculating performance bonuses or is stretching the envelope like Shopify, it pays to put some time and thought into the way bonuses are determined and distributed. If employees believe that a bonus structure is inherently unfair, instead of motivating them to excel, bonus time may usher them out the door.


Subscribe to the TribeHR Blog for more on what’s relevant to HR today!

Creating a Path for Growth

Posted on by Leave a Comment

 Photo Credit: Nicholas A. Tonelli, Flikr Research shows that one of the most important attractors in a job search (and one of the strongest incentives for existing employees to stay with an organization), is the availability of growth opportunities. At the same time, company structures are becoming flatter, with fewer levels of management and less hierarchy. These increasingly horizontal organizational structures have resulted in more lateral movement and “cross training” to support career development aspirations. Some people find scaling the “career lattice” more satisfying than the traditional approach to climbing the corporate ladder. But there …

Forget Global: What Happens When the Workforce Goes Galactic?

Posted on by Leave a Comment

If we’ve learned one thing in HR during the past decade, it’s that change is upon us. And there is no reason to expect things to move at a slower pace going forward. Even as we grapple with the reality of an increasingly global workforce, a number of recent news items are triggering an even more fantastical train of thought—what happens when the workforce goes galactic? Mars Orbit Undocking by SpaceGuy5, Wikimedia Commons Who cares, you say? That’s so far in the future it can’t possibly impact us.   …

Soccer by Any Other Name: The Workplace and the World Cup

Posted on by Leave a Comment

World Cup 2014 by Thomas, Wikimedia Commons Whether you call it soccer, football or the beautiful game, it has unquestionably united the sentiments of millions of people around the globe. In fact, the FIFA World Cup is the biggest single-event sporting competition in the world and the most watched sporting event on the planet. So much so, that one week into the competition, advertisers had already benefited from over 1.2 billion minutes of TV and online ad viewing by a voracious global fan-base. The patriotism and passion the sport evokes is legendary. For the people of participating nations, the World Cup represents …

When an Employee Feels Underpaid

Posted on by Leave a Comment

Overworked, underpaid and under-appreciated is the current mood of many workers across the country. According to a survey conducted by employment site,, 39 percent of people do not feel they are being compensated fairly in their current jobs. Women still bear the brunt of this, with 42% of women who responded feeling they’re unfairly paid, compared to one third of the men who answered the survey. Wikimedia Commons, Public Domain The disparity between CEO’s compensation and that of front-line workers is also a constant source of tension, especially in larger corporations. According to the AFL-CIO[1], …

Get Engaged With A Globalized Workforce

Posted on by Leave a Comment

The Internet is arguably the greatest communications and technological achievement society has so far attained. If technology were to fail us, as it does in the post-apocalyptic future J. J. Abrams creates in the NBC series, Revolution, we would look back on the first two decades of the 21st-century and marvel at the incredible power each of us had at our disposal. Earth by Azcolvin429, Wikimedia Commons Thanks to the Internet, we are perpetually connected and no one is constrained by geography anymore. When it comes to sourcing staff, this creates an enormous opportunity—one we have never been …

Why HR Should Toss the Annual Compensation Review

Posted on by Leave a Comment

Wikimedia Commons, Public Domain Most of us are familiar with the annual performance review process (whether we like it or not!). In addition to annual performance reviews, some companies also implement an annual compensation review process. Sometimes the compensation review is linked to the performance review process, and sometimes it’s not. But regardless of how it’s positioned, the annual compensation review is one potentially destructive practice. What Drives Annual Compensation Reviews? When a company chooses to review compensation on an annual basis, the decision is generally driven by a Finance process rather than an HR process. …

Compensation Equity

Posted on by Leave a Comment

Arriving at fair compensation is not always easy. Aside from the fact that each position has a unique value to an organization and not all jobs are created equal, employers also face the challenge of recognizing and rewarding exemplary performance in a given role. Add to that the fact that people seldom agree on what’s fair and compensation design becomes that much more complicated. Freedom or Fairness by Nina Paley, Wikimedia Commons, Creative Commons Employees consider two things when assessing whether their own compensation is fair. How their compensation compares to their co-workers. How their compensation compares to …

Compensation Design: Beyond Foundational Needs

Posted on by Leave a Comment

US Treasury, Wikimedia Commons, Public Domain We spend a lot of time thinking about (and writing about) employee motivation,engagement and what it takes to create an awesome work environment with a high performance culture. But, before we can turn our sights to creating that awesome environment, there are some basics that must be addressed. As Maslow discovered, people are motivated by different things depending on their current state. This means that people’s foundational (physiological) needs must be met before more complex needs even hit their radar. In the context of the workplace, foundational needs typically relate to …

Managing Multiple Generations in the Workplace

Posted on by Leave a Comment

The face of today’s workforce is changing and the pace of that change is unprecedented. As the typical retirement age moves up and another generation enters the workplace, human capital management will continue to become more complex. Wikimedia Commons, Public Domain The Millennial Influx In Mentoring Millennials, a Harvard Business Review article, the authors state: “The makeup of the global workforce is undergoing a seismic shift: In four years Millennials—the people born between 1977 and 1997—will account for nearly half the employees in the world. In some companies, they already constitute a majority.” In …

Next Page

Experience TribeHR for Yourself
Contact us to schedule a demo of TribeHR.

Book A Demo
The Latest from Workplace Tribes
Two Approaches to Calculating Bonuses August 20, 2014
Creating a Path for Growth August 18, 2014
3 Things HR Can Learn from Great Customer Service August 15, 2014
Brain Health and Workplace Performance August 13, 2014
Are Leadership Skills Transferable? August 11, 2014
Presentation Skills - Using the Tools of the Speakers Trade August 08, 2014
Communication: Words Matter August 06, 2014
Paid Wedding Leave – Not! August 04, 2014
How Not to Communicate Mass Layoffs August 01, 2014
20 Secrets of the World’s Greatest Coaches July 30, 2014